
Decorated DYE-FREE sugar cookies for all seasons & special occasions!
Located in Lakeland, FL & shipping nationwide :)
Featured Items (Available This Summer)
-
Lemonade Stand (Strawberry Lemonade)
Regular price $10.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Summer Fun Minis (Classic Sugar)
Regular price $10.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
The Pink Piggy (Classic Sugar)
Regular price $6.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Afternoon Tea (Earl Grey)
Regular price $10.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Cool Treats (Classic Sugar)
Regular price $12.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Love At First Cookie: The Monthly Box
Regular price $40.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per
Need a custom order? A specific quantity? Celebrating? Something else?

Our Story
We're the Baileys!
I'm Nicole! I have been married to my husband Channon for 15 years, have 4 amazing kids, 1 dog, 5 cats, 6 chickens, & 3 donkeys, plus some resident ducks all while residing on our little piece of land in ole Florida.
Baking has always been a way to show my love to people! There's just something about a warm plate of cookies or baked goods when you walk into someone's house!
I've baked for over 3 decades, but as 40 got closer, I decided it was time to pursue a dream I'd had in the back of my head for a while - decorated sugar cookies with unique flavor combinations that actually tasted good!
And so Love at First Cookie was born! Know that every cookie is baked from scratch, without artificial dyes, and with love from me to you!